Attorneys for the Osage Nation argued on Tuesday that an appeals court should affirm the tribe's reservation.
While many tribes saw their reservations reaffirmed following McGirt v. Oklahoma, the 2020 U.S. Supreme Court case that decided the Muscogee Nation was never disestablished, the Osage Nation was not one of them.
In 2010, Tenth Circuit judges ruled in Osage Nation v. Irby that Congress had disestablished the reservation. The case questioned whether the Oklahoma Tax Commission, of which Constance Irby was a member, could collect taxes on Osage citizens living and working within the nation.
Following McGirt, the tribe sought to appeal the decision. But a federal judge said he couldn't rule because the court wasn't active in the case, though the tribe could begin a new case.
Eugene Bertman, representing Osage Nation, told Tenth Circuit judges Tuesday that there is no statutory language that disestablishes the reservation. He said the tribe is only seeking judgment on its reservation status, stating the tribe cannot litigate taxation without first addressing Irby.
"There is no court that I can find that has identified any particular language from any statute that points to secession," Bertman said. "This court noted, even in Irby, that the Enabling Act nor the Allotment Act identified any specific language disestablishing the nation."
But Oklahoma Solicitor General Garry Gaskins, arguing on behalf of the Oklahoma Tax Commission, claimed the Oklahoma Enabling Act of 1906 turned the Osage reservation into Osage County.
"The Osage Nation is now a county in the state of Oklahoma," Gaskins said. " ... And so 15 years ago, this court ruled that it was disestablished. And then four-and-a-half years later the Supreme Court came out with a decision in McGirt which dealt with a different tribe, the Muscogee Creek, that have a different history, different statutes, different treaties."
Gaskins added the case is not about whether the reservation still exists, but if the tribe can reopen a final judgment after the 2010 decision.
Meanwhile, Bertman cites a federal rule, which allows courts to grant relief for a previous decision when new evidence is found, mistakes are made or it is applied inequitably after the fact.
The outcome of McGirt, Bertman argued, demonstrates inequity because Osage Nation did not see its reservation reaffirmed, unlike its neighboring tribes.
Senior Judge Michael Murphy pressed Gaskins on the rule.
"It appears to me that there's a substantial argument of unfairness here," Murphy said.
Gaskins responded by stating a change of law rarely justifies relief.
Osage Nation Principal Chief Joe Tillman released a statement on social media yesterday saying the argument represents Osage history and sovereignty.
"No matter the outcome of today's proceedings, one thing remains certain: our identity, our history, our heritage, and our connection to our homeland cannot be taken from us," Tillman wrote.
The case
Osage Nation's current case dates back to 2001, when then-Principal Chief Charles Tillman sued the Oklahoma Tax Commission, arguing it couldn't tax tribal citizens working and living on the reservation.
That case became Osage Nation v. Irby, named after tax commission member Constance Irby. In 2010, the court ruled the reservation was disestablished. Osage Nation argues that ruling was based on "extratextual evidence," such as historian opinions and demographic changes, rather than statutory language.
Following McGirt v. Oklahoma, which affirmed the Muscogee Nation reservation was never disestablished, multiple tribes received similar confirmations that their reservations were intact, including the Cherokee, Seminole, Chickasaw and Choctaw Nations. But Osage Nation did not.
The tribe sought relief in 2025, asking the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Oklahoma to throw out the 2010 Irby ruling. A year later, a federal judge denied the tribe's request, saying the court was no longer involved in the case and recommending tribal leaders file a new lawsuit.
Now, the tribe argues McGirt should override the 2010 ruling, adding that only Congress can determine whether a reservation still exists.
This article was first published by Kosu.